https://www.americancityandcounty.com/wp-content/themes/acc_child/assets/images/logo/footer-logo.png
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcast
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Events
    • How to Contribute
    • Municipal Cost Index – Archive
    • Equipment Watch Page
    • American City & County Awards
  • Magazine
    • Back
    • Digital Editions
    • Reprints & Reuse
    • Advertise
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Service
American City and County
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcasts
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Events
    • How to Contribute
    • American City & County Awards
    • Municipal Cost Index
    • Equipment Watch Page
  • Magazine
    • Back
    • Digital Editions
    • Reprints & Reuse
    • Subscribe to GovPro
    • Manage GovPro Subscription
    • Advertise
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Stament
    • Terms of Service
  • newsletter
  • Administration
  • Economy & Finance
  • Procurement
  • Public Safety
  • Public Works & Utilities
  • Smart Cities & Technology
acc.com

Public Safety


Image via Pixabay

Article

Probabilistic genotyping in forensic DNA analysis

Probabilistic genotyping in forensic DNA analysis

Despite some criticisms, the use of PG software is an advancement that substantially improves DNA analysis
  • Written by Bruce Budowle
  • 30th November 2020

Since forensic DNA probabilistic genotyping (PG) software was introduced nearly a decade ago, its use by federal, state, and local forensic laboratories has increased substantially.

PG software makes better use of the information contained in a DNA profile than traditional approaches. As a result, DNA profiles once discarded as uninformative are now accessible for inculpating and exculpating potential donors of forensic biological evidence. Users of PG software have been able to improve their ability to interpret low-level, degraded, and mixture DNA profiles, positively impacting interpretation of DNA results from a wide range of evidence.

 

Benefits of Enhancing Interpretation of DNA Evidence

The advent of PG software has enabled forensic analysts to interpret more challenging DNA profiles with greater efficacy and at a much higher degree of accuracy than any interpretational approach previously used.

PG software has proven particularly effective in producing usable, interpretable, and valid DNA results in criminal cases, and excluding individuals wrongly associated as the source of crime scene evidence. PG tools have also been instrumental in helping to solve cold cases in which evidence originally dismissed as inconclusive could be reanalyzed, helping to develop investigative leads and support exonerations in post-conviction cases.

Employing methods like Markov Chain Monte Carlo that are routinely used in computational biology, physics, engineering, weather prediction, and the stock market, PG software grades proposed profiles on how closely they resemble or can explain an observed DNA mixture profile. From there, the probability of the observed DNA evidence can be calculated under two propositions – if the DNA originated from a person of interest or if the DNA originated from an unknown donor. These two probabilities are then presented as a likelihood ratio.

PG software has been validated, as described in a large number of peer-reviewed papers, supporting general reliability. These supporting data have been a foundation for the admissibility of PG software in an overwhelming majority of court cases. Issues raised (such as the software being a black box, access to source code, and potential miscodes) have not gained traction because the supporting data demonstrate scientific validity.

 

Limitations to Consider

The primary limitation of PG software, as with any methodology, is that it cannot perform miracles. Some DNA profiles have too little information or are too complex to interpret with any PG tool. It is incumbent upon users to perform validation studies to understand the limitations of the tools they employ. By doing so, users will reduce chances of interpreting software output that is not supportable. It is important to understand that the trained user is an integral part of the interpretation of DNA evidence.

Another limitation is the false belief that using PG software renders all such interpretations completely objective. The choice of algorithms and programming are by humans and thus, subjectivity is inherent in the software. Using such software, however, can reduce the variation among users and decrease user variation community-wide.

 

Challenges to Admissibility

Despite the demonstrated power of PG software, it is not unexpected that, as with most methods in the forensic field, some criticisms have been encountered. First and foremost, our legal system promotes criticism of methods used in legal proceedings, which benefits all and should be embraced.

Second, advocates for the use of a method should perform the proper studies, understand the fundamentals of the method, and apply it properly. If such practices are undertaken, a laboratory should have confidence that its use of PG software is reliable.

Third, some criticize PG software, claiming it has not been subjected to adequate independent peer-review because the inventors are authors of most publications. Peer-review is an important part of science. A paper with an inventor as the author is information, and should be considered in context with papers by others and with validation studies undertaken by each laboratory.

It also is important to recognize that publication of a paper is just one part of the peer-review process. All publications (and presentations at scientific meetings) inform the community, foster discussion, and move science forward. The more effective part of peer-review comes once papers are published. If data and interpretations seem suspect or improvements can be identified, the greater scientific community can comment, critique, and perform studies to demonstrate flaws or alternatives. We should not be misdirected that such authored papers do not provide meaningful data, as the initial paper is only part of the peer-review process. To date, the overall peer-review process has favored that PG software can generate reliable results when used properly.

Finally, some assert PG software contains (or may contain) miscodes which may impact its reliability. The only software that can realistically claim to have no miscodes is the software that has not been written. Stating there may be a miscode is likely to be true. The real questions, though, are: 1) have there been and/or are there mechanisms in place to detect miscodes; 2) what is the impact of a miscode when identified; and 3) are identified miscodes rectified? While the source code of some PG software has been reviewed by individuals outside of the commercial entity, miscodes to date have been identified almost exclusively by examining extended output, which contains the intermediate steps of the interpretation process.

 

Despite some criticisms, the use of PG software is an advancement that substantially improves DNA analysis. It will undoubtedly continue to have a profound impact on criminal and civil investigations, providing reliable data from a broader range of DNA evidence and in particular complex mixtures.

To promote obtaining reliable interpretations, forensic laboratories need to: 1) ensure their scientists receive proper training on the principles, practices, and data generated by PG software; 2) properly validate their PG software, which includes in-house studies and reliance on peer-reviewed literature; 3) implement effective protocols so as not to overstate the strength of PG results; and 4) address criticisms that are raised which have merit.

 

 

Bruce Budowle, PhD is a Professor at the University of North Texas Health Science Center, where he is involved in the research and validation of forensic genetics and molecular genetics methodologies. He also is Director of the Center for Human Identification. Prior to his current positions, Dr. Budowle served 26 years with the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Over the years, he held a number of positions within the FBI Laboratory, including research chemist, chief of the Forensic Science Research Unit, and senior scientist in biology.   

Tags: homepage-featured-3 homepage-featured-4 Public Safety Public Safety Article

Related


  • Public safety needs a better way to triage emergency calls
    The overarching goal of the public-safety community is to ensure that 911 callers receive the most appropriate emergency response as quickly as possible. Lives often are on the line in an emergency, and every second matters. Achieving a balance between sending the optimal response to an emergency and having it arrive as fast as possible […]
  • Florida county announces successful test of Motorola Solutions’ cloud-based P25 core technology
    A Florida county recently announced the completion of a successful test of Motorola Solutions’ CirrusCentral Core, the cloud-based secondary core for ASTRO 25 P25 systems that is designed to provide redundant reliability to the land-mobile-radio (LMR) network without the costs associated with a physical secondary core site. In Sumter County, Fla., the absence of a […]
  • D.C. police begin identifying Capitol rioters
    Washington, D.C.’s Metropolitan Police Department (MPD) is working with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to identify the supporters of President Donald Trump who stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6. “MPD seeks assistance in identifying persons of interest responsible for Unlawful Entry offenses that occurred yesterday on US Capitol Grounds, 100 block of 1st […]
  • FirstNet Authority releases new details about impact of Nashville explosion on broadband system
    Public-safety subscribers to FirstNet responding to the Dec. 25 massive explosion near the AT&T network hub in Nashville experienced a four-hour outage when some services were not rerouted prior to deployable cell sites becoming operational at the scene, according to a FirstNet Authority blog. Released Friday evening, the FirstNet Authority blog reiterated several facts previously […]

Leave a comment Cancel reply

-or-

Log in with your American City and County account

Alternatively, post a comment by completing the form below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • Colorado county refuses to enforce state orders as COVID-19 level increases
  • Hamilton County elects first female, openly gay sheriff
  • Oregon decriminalizes possession of hard drugs in historic ballot vote
  • Facing the controversy of facial recognition technology

White papers


How a unified HR system helps one public safety organization manage crews, payroll, and more in a single platform

7th January 2021

Your Roadmap to COVID-19 Funding

18th December 2020

The One Where Everyone Wins: A Mutually Beneficial Contracting Method

10th December 2020
view all

Events


PODCAST


Young Leaders Episode 4 – Cyril Jefferson – City Councilman, High Point, North Carolina

13th October 2020

Young Leaders Episode 3 – Shannon Hardin – City Council President, Columbus, Ohio

27th July 2020

Young Leaders Episode 2 – Christian Williams – Development Services Planner, Goodyear, Ariz.

1st July 2020
view all

Twitter


AmerCityCounty

The latest episode The Young Leaders Podcast focuses on Cyril Jefferson. Cyril is the youngest African American to… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

27th October 2020
AmerCityCounty

Hillsboro, Oregon is pioneering a new #renewableenergy generation technology through a partnership with… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

27th October 2020
AmerCityCounty

The impact of the #COVID19 pandemic on #telework was swift and profound. Now, the big question is whether – and to… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

26th October 2020
AmerCityCounty

Get ready for the can't-miss webinar on how to kickstart your efficiency improvement plan with Luke Anderson of… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

26th October 2020
AmerCityCounty

Among all states headed into the 2020 general election, which ones have voting populations that are the most demogr… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

26th October 2020
AmerCityCounty

We want to hear from you! Share your thoughts in our readership survey to help us shape future content so that we c… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

23rd October 2020
AmerCityCounty

See how cities different approaches to distribute masks in their communities >> spr.ly/6010GAPLa

23rd October 2020
AmerCityCounty

While #facialrecognition is a powerful tool that can improve law enforcement efficiency, that doesn’t necessarily t… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

23rd October 2020

Newsletters

Sign up for American City & County’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about local governments.

Resale Insights Dashboard

The Resale Insights Dashboard provides model-level data for the entire used equipment market to help you save time and money.

Municipal Cost Index

Updated monthly since 1978, our exclusive Municipal Cost Index shows the effects of inflation on the cost of providing municipal services

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital audience? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • IWCE’s Urgent Communications
  • IWCE Expo

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us

FOLLOW American City and County ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2021 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X