https://www.americancityandcounty.com/wp-content/themes/acc_child/assets/images/logo/footer-logo.png
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Hybrid Work
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcast
  • Resources & Events
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • IWCE 2022
    • How to Contribute
    • Municipal Cost Index – Archive
    • Equipment Watch Page
    • American City & County Awards
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Service
American City and County
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Hybrid Work
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcasts
  • Resources/Events
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers/eBooks
    • IWCE 2022
    • How to Contribute
    • American City & County Awards
    • Municipal Cost Index
    • Equipment Watch Page
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Stament
    • Terms of Service
  • newsletter
  • Administration
  • Economy & Finance
  • Procurement
  • Public Safety
  • Public Works & Utilities
  • Smart Cities & Technology
  • Magazine
acc.com


Court ruling could affect environmental laws

Court ruling could affect environmental laws

On March 27, 1996, in Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida, the U. S. Supreme Court considered whether private parties may sue states in federal court.
  • Written by Reynolds, Jeffrey
  • 1st July 1996

On March 27, 1996, in Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida, the U. S. Supreme Court considered whether private parties may sue states in federal court. In a 5-4 decision, the court determined that federal legislation cannot override the .sovereign immunity granted to the states by the 11th Amendment.

The decision seriously affects approximately half the states, where Indian gambling generates $6 billion in revenues annually, allowing states more leeway in regulating casino gambling on Indian reservations.

Many states and local governments see the case as a major victory in their fight to regulate unwelcome gam bring on nearby Native American lands. Despite the revenues it generates, marry local officials view gambling as a drain that provides few economic benefits and does nothing to solve local unemployment since Native American casinos traditionally employ only Native Americans.

Seminole arose because of a dispute under the 1988 Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, which provides a statutory basis for the operation and regulation of gaming by Native American tribes. Under the act, tribes are allowed to conduct certain gaming activities in accordance with a compact between the tribe and the state where the gaming activities are located.

States are required to negotiate in good faith with a tribe to develop a compact. If a state does not do so, a tribe may sue in federal court. In the Seminole case, Florida successfully fought the Seminole Tribe’s complaint on the ground that the action violated Florida’s sovereign immunity from suit in federal court.

Although Seminole arose because of a dispute under the act, it affects several areas of federal law in which private enforcement is an integral part of the regulatory scheme.

The opinion does not simply preclude Congress from establishing the rather curious statutory scheme under which Indian tribes may seek the aid of a federal court to secure a state’s good faith negotiations over gaming regurations. “Rather, it prevents Congress from providing a federal forum for a broad range of actions against states, from those sounding in copyright and patent law, to those concerning bankruptcy, environmental law and the regulation of our vast national economy,” wrote Justice John Paul Stevens in the dissent.

The decision directly affects environmental laws, such as the Clean Air Act; the Clean Water Act; the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA); the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA); and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA), that include private enforcement and citizen suit provisions allowing private action against states and local governments failing to comply with federal regulations.

Those citizen suit provisions are unconstitutional, according to the majority opinion in the case, because Congress may not waive a state’s constitutionally provided sovereign immunity.

In so holding, the Supreme Court has disabled Congress’ initiative to privatize the enforcement of federal environmental laws at a time when federal enforcement funds are low and centralized federal bureaucracy is high. Seminole may free states from the burden of citizen suits, but it leaves questions about equal application of the law between state and local governments, as well as individuals, corporations and the federal government.

Under CERCLA, for instance, the ruling will prevent a corporation or federal agency from seeking federal court resolution of a liability–apportionment dispute with a state that is among the parties responsible for a site’s con lamination, thus increasing the burden of clean-up costs on private parties and federal agencies and reducing it on state and local governments.

In ether words, states will not be forced to pay their share if no objective forum exists for enforcement. A number of states have enacted mini-Superfund statutes that waive sovereign immunity without federal mandate.

But a state without such a waiver is unlikely to subject itself to potential damages for a Superfund cleanup. Public pressure, of course, may be a determining factor, and the experience will vary from state to state.

The same problem does not appear to be present in environmental compliance and corrective action. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of Justice can get around the 11th Amendment through their normal enforcement powers by suing officials of the responsible state agency by name instead of suing the state itself.

Injunctive relief can still be obtained under another Supreme Court decision, Ex parse Young, to remedy a state officer’s ongoing violation of federal law. State and local government officials should be especially cognizant of this case.

Finally, Congress still has some leverage to compel states to waive sovereign immunity.

It can indirectly compel a state to waive sovereign immunity by making federal funds available only to states that have waiver provisions.

For example, EPA recently issued a rule stating that state wastewater discharge permitting programs must include judicial review provisions that allow citizens to challenge final permit decisions in court.

States have until June 7, 1997, to revise their NPOES programs or risk disapproval of their programs and funding by EPA.

This article was written by Jefferson Reynolds, Deputy Regional Counsel, Air Force Legal Services Agency, Environmental Law & Litigation, Atlanta.

Tags:

Most Recent


  • Supreme Court ruling on EPA greenhouse gas regulation will impact cities
    On Thursday, the U.S. Supreme Court handcuffed the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)’s regulation power by ruling that the federal government cannot use the 1970 Clean Air Act to restrict greenhouse gas emissions from power plants. By a 6-3 decision, the decision is notable for city and county administrators because greenhouse gas emissions aren’t contained within […]
  • sustainability
    Sustainability initiatives take center stage in Florida county
    Palm Beach County, Fla. (2022 estimated population: 1,538,450), is the second largest county in Florida by land area and the third largest by population. County leaders have been implementing resiliency and sustainability initiatives for more than a decade, says Melissa McKinlay, commissioner of Palm Beach County District 6. “However, a few years ago, the Board […]
  • July fourth
    10 best cities for July Fourth celebrations
    Happy 247th birthday, America! Across the country, people will be gathering for parades, picnics and, of course, fireworks. According to WalletHub’s 4th of July facts, 47.9 million people will travel 50+ miles from home for the holiday weekend. They will spend $7.7 billion on food, and eat 150 million hot dogs, maybe trying to beat […]
  • The Missing Link in Cloud Security
    Why End-of-Life Destruction is Critical to a Successful Cloud Security Policy Recently, there has been a hyper-focus on cloud security — and with good reason. According to a report by McAfee, cloud services are now a regular component of IT operations, utilized by more than 90% of organizations globally. In fact, 80% of all IT […]

Leave a comment Cancel reply

-or-

Log in with your American City and County account

Alternatively, post a comment by completing the form below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • NLC releases State of Cities 2021 report
  • How governments can keep employees safe as they return to work
  • Lessons from your friendly neighborhood public service employees
  • North Texas alliance partners with Marketplace.city on smart government solutions

White papers


How to Assemble a Rockstar Website Redesign Steering Committee

7th June 2022

Hand Hygiene: Compliance Matters

23rd May 2022

What it Takes to Build a Winning Esports Program

23rd May 2022
view all

Events


PODCAST


Young Leaders Episode 4 – Cyril Jefferson – City Councilman, High Point, North Carolina

13th October 2020

Young Leaders Episode 3 – Shannon Hardin – City Council President, Columbus, Ohio

27th July 2020

Young Leaders Episode 2 – Christian Williams – Development Services Planner, Goodyear, Ariz.

1st July 2020
view all

Twitter


AmerCityCounty

Supreme Court ruling on EPA greenhouse gas regulation will impact cities dlvr.it/STBwkw

1st July 2022
AmerCityCounty

Sustainability initiatives take center stage in Florida county dlvr.it/STBvwN

1st July 2022
AmerCityCounty

10 best cities for July Fourth celebrations dlvr.it/STBfHt

1st July 2022
AmerCityCounty

The Missing Link in Cloud Security dlvr.it/STBXNL

1st July 2022
AmerCityCounty

Improving Productivity with Employee Engagement | Aug. 4, 2022 at 2 PM ET dlvr.it/STBCD5

1st July 2022
AmerCityCounty

We want to hear from you! Please take this brief survey and let us know how your organization is managing your budg… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

30th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Report: Reforming emergency dispatch won’t be easy, but it’s necessary dlvr.it/ST7kQ5

30th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Three U.S. cities to adopt Bloomberg Philanthropies Mayors Challenge-winning project to combat climate change dlvr.it/ST4bjk

29th June 2022

Newsletters

Sign up for American City & County’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about local governments.

Resale Insights Dashboard

The Resale Insights Dashboard provides model-level data for the entire used equipment market to help you save time and money.

Municipal Cost Index

Updated monthly since 1978, our exclusive Municipal Cost Index shows the effects of inflation on the cost of providing municipal services

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital audience? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • IWCE’s Urgent Communications
  • IWCE Expo

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us

FOLLOW American City and County ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2022 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X