https://www.americancityandcounty.com/wp-content/themes/acc_child/assets/images/logo/footer-logo.png
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Hybrid Work
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcast
  • Resources & Events
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • IWCE 2022
    • How to Contribute
    • Municipal Cost Index – Archive
    • Equipment Watch Page
    • American City & County Awards
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Service
American City and County
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Hybrid Work
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcasts
  • Resources/Events
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers/eBooks
    • IWCE 2022
    • How to Contribute
    • American City & County Awards
    • Municipal Cost Index
    • Equipment Watch Page
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Stament
    • Terms of Service
  • newsletter
  • Administration
  • Economy & Finance
  • Procurement
  • Public Safety
  • Public Works & Utilities
  • Smart Cities & Technology
  • Magazine
acc.com


Appellate court upholds types of flow control

Appellate court upholds types of flow control

The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has handed down two decisions that should have a substantial impact on municipal governments
  • Written by American City & County Administrator
  • 1st November 1995

The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has handed down two decisions that should have a substantial impact on municipal governments and the solid waste management industry. The decisions uphold two different, non-regulatory means by which municipalities may control the flow of municipal solid waste. With its findings, the court applied the brakes to a judicial trend that, since Clarkstown v. Carbone, has been invalidating almost every system that involved controlling the flow of solid waste.

SSC Corp. v. Town of Smithtown and USA Recycling v. Town of Babylon both involved challenges to solid waste management programs developed by two Long Island, N.Y., towns in response to the court’s finding in Carbone that a Clarkstown flow control law violated the Commerce Clause of the Constitution.

The programs in question abandoned attempts at regulatory flow control — laws and ordinances directing commercial haulers to specific destinations.

Instead, the two towns took over the collection of waste as market participants, contracted for a single hauler (using a competitive process) and paid for the service with taxes and other fees. Babylon’s contractor received free disposal service at the town facility; Smithtown’s paid a stated tipping fee at its facility and was obligated by contract to tip there.

The programs thus achieved “economic flow control” and “contract flow control” and may have established a precedent for future actions by municipalities.

In Smithtown’s case, the town created 10 residential garbage collection districts within its borders, solicited competitive bids for collection and disposal services in each district and signed contracts with the successful bidders.

The bid documents and the contracts specified that the garbage collected was required to be disposed of at the town’s preferred incinerator in nearby Huntington. Additionally, Smithtown passed an ordinance mandating that waste collected within its borders go to the incinerator.

Eventually, the contractor that won the bid on seven of the districts argued that Carbone invalidated the town’s flow control ordinance, and thus it was not bound by the terms of the contract.

The court agreed with the first part but held that the contractual provision regarding the incinerator was binding nonetheless, reasoning that the town was “buying” disposal services and had the right to buy them wherever it chose.

In the Babylon case, the town’s single hauler of commercial waste was paid by the town, which permitted it to dispose of up to 96,000 tons of the garbage per year at its incinerator free of charge.

Unsuccessful bidders for the collection contract and other waste processing facilities challenged the constitutionality of the system. The court disagreed with the plaintiffs, upholding every aspect of Babylon’s solid waste management program.

It explained that what the town had done was exercise its longstanding traditional right to take over the collection of garbage and provide basic sanitation collection and disposal as a governmental service to the businesses in the district, analogizing the deal to police or fire protection.

By so doing, the court said, the town had eliminated the market for collection services, denying both in- and out-of-state haulers access to the market.

It concluded that eliminating the market does not result in discrimination against interstate commerce, since all haulers are equally denied access.

Following the Commerce Clause precedent, the court examined whether the burden on interstate commerce of taking over collection and placing the right of collection in the hands of an independent contractor outweighed the benefits. It found that, despite minor effects, it did not, and that Babylon was protecting a legitimate and compelling interest.

Tags:

Most Recent


  • Report: Local and state governments are facing a retention crisis; the worst could be yet to come
    When the pandemic struck in 2020, public retention was hit hard: jobs in local government plummeted by 8.5 percent; state employment dropped by 4.4 percent. Two years later, local and state government jobs have rebounded by about half—to 4.1 and 1.9 percent below pre-pandemic levels respectively, according to a new report from Mission Square Research […]
  • Amid an unprecedented increase in federal spending, cities and counties stand to benefit from partnerships
    The so-called “American dream” of upward mobility has more or less stagnated: Today, a little more than 40 percent of children raised at the bottom of the income ladder remain there as adults, according to Pew Charitable Trusts, and only half grow up to earn more than their parents. This data points to a concerning […]
  • hybrid technology
    Governments using technology to harness data and improve decision-making
    There’s one kind of technology that state and local governments covet, says Rob Carey, president of Cloudera Government Solutions. “While supporting multiple state and local government agencies, our team has noticed an increase in the need for hybrid cloud solutions.” A hybrid cloud is the combination of both public and private cloud deployment models. In […]
  • Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue, WA
    Infrastructure highlighted by city leaders as top priority in analysis of 60 mayoral addresses
    After two years of ping-pong lockdown orders, mask mandates, unprecedented vaccine drives and economic uncertainty, cities across the United States are beginning to emerge in the pandemic’s aftermath, and they’re prioritizing infrastructure, according to a report published Wednesday by the National League of Cities (NLC).  “The new normal, as we now understand it, is here,” […]

Leave a comment Cancel reply

-or-

Log in with your American City and County account

Alternatively, post a comment by completing the form below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • Harris County deploys next-generation security in 150 public buildings
  • Public procurement can be transformative for stakeholders in a community
  • The 10 Most Sustainable Large U.S. Cities
  • How local governments can get ahead of the infrastructure wave: Strategies to mitigate risk

White papers


How to Assemble a Rockstar Website Redesign Steering Committee

7th June 2022

Hand Hygiene: Compliance Matters

23rd May 2022

What it Takes to Build a Winning Esports Program

23rd May 2022
view all

Events


PODCAST


Young Leaders Episode 4 – Cyril Jefferson – City Councilman, High Point, North Carolina

13th October 2020

Young Leaders Episode 3 – Shannon Hardin – City Council President, Columbus, Ohio

27th July 2020

Young Leaders Episode 2 – Christian Williams – Development Services Planner, Goodyear, Ariz.

1st July 2020
view all

Twitter


AmerCityCounty

Report: Local and state governments are facing a retention crisis; the worst could be yet to come dlvr.it/SSnmS7

24th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Amid an unprecedented increase in federal spending, cities and counties stand to benefit from partnerships dlvr.it/SSkGBn

23rd June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Governments using technology to harness data and improve decision-making dlvr.it/SSk3H0

23rd June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Infrastructure highlighted by city leaders as top priority in analysis of 60 mayoral addresses dlvr.it/SSgBck

22nd June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Oklahoma City puts the focus on employees when implementing changes in office technology dlvr.it/SSfyns

22nd June 2022
AmerCityCounty

We want to hear from you! Please take this brief survey and let us know how your organization is managing your budg… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

22nd June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Buying smart solutions: Technology is now part of (almost) every government purchase dlvr.it/SSbj3Z

21st June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Amid tech labor shortage, outsourcing digital services could provide relief dlvr.it/SSbj23

21st June 2022

Newsletters

Sign up for American City & County’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about local governments.

Resale Insights Dashboard

The Resale Insights Dashboard provides model-level data for the entire used equipment market to help you save time and money.

Municipal Cost Index

Updated monthly since 1978, our exclusive Municipal Cost Index shows the effects of inflation on the cost of providing municipal services

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital audience? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • IWCE’s Urgent Communications
  • IWCE Expo

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us

FOLLOW American City and County ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2022 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X