https://www.americancityandcounty.com/wp-content/themes/acc_child/assets/images/logo/footer-logo.png
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Hybrid Work
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcast
  • Resources & Events
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • IWCE 2022
    • How to Contribute
    • Municipal Cost Index – Archive
    • Equipment Watch Page
    • American City & County Awards
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Service
American City and County
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • Co-op Solutions
  • Hybrid Work
  • Commentaries
  • News
  • In-Depth
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Podcasts
  • Resources/Events
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers/eBooks
    • IWCE 2022
    • How to Contribute
    • American City & County Awards
    • Municipal Cost Index
    • Equipment Watch Page
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Stament
    • Terms of Service
  • newsletter
  • Administration
  • Economy & Finance
  • Procurement
  • Public Safety
  • Public Works & Utilities
  • Smart Cities & Technology
  • Magazine
acc.com

Commentaries


Commentary

Does constitutional substantive due process protection apply to camera enforcement?

Does constitutional substantive due process protection apply to camera enforcement?

Mark Mulholland, a partner at Ruskin Moscou Faltischek, P.C., discusses the constitutionality of camera enforcement.
  • Written by contributor
  • 22nd April 2015

By Mark S. Mulholland

A due process lawsuit, which was filed against a New York county traffic enforcement agency by a plaintiff who had received a violation ticket generated by a red light camera was recently dismissed in its entirety by the Eastern District of the United States District Court.

Over the last few years, municipalities across the country have increasingly utilized camera enforcement of red light, failure to stop, or speeding violations.  Typical arguments raised against these programs in community forums or the media center around a debate of ‘safety versus revenue.’  Those implementing the program point to studies that show a reduction in accidents as the result of increased camera enforcement; while those opposing (who most often are the recipients of a recent ticket) will decry the measure as a push for increased revenue.

Setting aside the safety versus revenue argument, others have claimed that camera enforcement is a violation of constitutional rights and due process. Such was the argument in a United States Eastern District Court case.

The plaintiff, who received a red light camera violation from the Nassau County Traffic and Parking Violations Agency and paid the $65 fine and surcharge without contest, filed suit claiming violation of the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment, as well as the New York State constitution.

Substantive Due Process protection under the US Constitution has long been interpreted to apply to a narrow band of the most fundamental of human rights – such as marriage, family, procreation, bodily integrity – and courts have consistently resisted attempts to expand the definition of substantive due process.

In dismissing the suit, Justice Arthur D. Spatt concurred with the defendant’s arguments that the plaintiff’s claims did not rise to the level of substantive due process under the federal and state constitutions.

In short, the right to be free from a $65 red light ticket does not fall under those very specific and fundamental rights protected by the U.S. Constitution and substantive due process.

Ticket recipients, such as the one who filed this suit, may also pursue other arguments. Here the suit also included a claim for ‘unjust enrichment,’ based on non-specific, anecdotal allegations that the timing of yellow lights may have been decreased in order to increase the number of violations. This claim was found to be without substantiation, and as it was duplicative of the faulty due process argument, was dismissed.

Also dismissed was the claim for declaratory judgment and an order to enjoin the operation of an expansive red light camera program in Nassau County, a large, suburban county on Long Island with a population of 1.3 million.

It is likely that many motorists who receive a violation from an enforcement camera wonder if their constitutional their rights have been infringed.  To keep these programs in place, municipalities need to be prepared for the inevitable citizen-crusader lawsuit.

Mark Mulholland is a partner at Ruskin Moscou Faltischek, P.C. (Uniondale, N.Y.) and senior member of the practice’s litigation group, with wide experience and success in municipal matters. For more than 45 years, Ruskin Moscou Faltischek, a sixty member professional firm, has built a reputation as one of the region’s leading providers of innovative legal services in all major practice areas of the law, including corporate and securities, financial services, commercial litigation, digital media, energy, intellectual property, health care, real estate, employment and trusts and estates.

Tags: Public Safety Commentaries Commentary

Most Recent


  • FirstNet Authority CTO highlights coverage-extension efforts as initial Band 14 buildout nears completion
    With AT&T almost done deploying the initial contracted FirstNet 700 MHz Band 14 infrastructure, the FirstNet Authority increasingly is focusing on solutions that will let public-safety users access the nationwide public-safety broadband network (NPSBN) when outside of terrestrial system, according to FirstNet officials. FirstNet Authority CTO Jeff Bratcher said that NPSBN contractor AT&T repeatedly has […]
  • Bipartisan group of local leaders, NLC send letter to Congress calling for gun safety legislation
    In the aftermath of several horrific mass shootings, legislators in Washington, D.C. are locked in a familiar debate over gun safety legislation. On Wednesday, survivors and victims of gun violence testified about their experiences to Congress, calling on lawmakers to take action. “I don’t want it to happen again,” said Miah Cerrillo, a fourth-grader at […]
  • Mayors call for peace, gun control legislation at annual conference
    The U.S. Conference of Mayors kicked off its 90th annual meeting Friday in Reno, Nev., with a call to action on gun control—a topic the advocacy organization has taken a strong stance on following recent mass shootings in Buffalo, N.Y.; Uvalde, Texas; and Tulsa, Okla. “It’s more important than ever that we recommit ourselves to […]
  • Texas community to form holistic mental health crisis response teams
    For decades, the responsibility of helping those experiencing a mental health crisis has fallen to police departments, and communities across the United States have grappled with the safety and effectiveness of this distribution of duties— wondering if there’s a better way to get constituents the help they need. When it comes to fielding mental health […]

Related Content

  • How governments can keep employees safe as they return to work
  • Preventing cyber-attacks needs to be a priority for local governments
  • Building community and officer wellness through data sharing
  • California city combines advanced technology with dedicated public safety team for comprehensive emergency management

Twitter


AmerCityCounty

Three U.S. cities to adopt Bloomberg Philanthropies Mayors Challenge-winning project to combat climate change dlvr.it/ST4bjk

29th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

10 cities ideal for hybrid or full-time telecommuters seeking an outdoor lifestyle dlvr.it/ST4T5g

29th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Take American City & County’s budgeting survey dlvr.it/ST0qQP

28th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Six cities and counties will take stock of underutilized assets in Rethinking Revenue incubator dlvr.it/ST0ZVp

28th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Seamless Cooperative Experience Saves Indiana City Exponentially in Time and Money dlvr.it/SSxp95

27th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

10 best large cities for fishing dlvr.it/SSxbSZ

27th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Generational differences present an opportunity to reinvent public sector service delivery dlvr.it/SSxbN7

27th June 2022
AmerCityCounty

Report: Local and state governments are facing a retention crisis; the worst could be yet to come dlvr.it/SSnmS7

24th June 2022

Newsletters

Sign up for American City & County’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about local governments.

Resale Insights Dashboard

The Resale Insights Dashboard provides model-level data for the entire used equipment market to help you save time and money.

Municipal Cost Index

Updated monthly since 1978, our exclusive Municipal Cost Index shows the effects of inflation on the cost of providing municipal services

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital audience? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • IWCE’s Urgent Communications
  • IWCE Expo

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us

FOLLOW American City and County ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2022 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X